Summer time Recreation Fest Does not Simply Strive Its Finest, It Tries Too Exhausting

After a PlayStation showcase earlier within the week, the annual online game promo circuit for the summer season started in earnest with that two-hour showcase by the identify of Summer Game Fest, which had teases, sequels, and wholly new video games galore.

Par for the course for SGF and host Geoff Keighley, each of which have endeavored to step up throughout this decade because the as soon as and superb commerce present king E3 has progressively died off. However this yr’s carried an odd air about it, even earlier than a Splitgate 2 developer walked onstage with a “Make FPS Great Again Hat” (actually) earlier than smacktalking “the identical Name of Responsibility” and revealing his shooter’s battle royale mode.

Quite a lot of that weirdness is as a result of the video games business goes via it proper now. It’s been over every week since EA killed its Black Panther game and developer Cliffhanger, and business layoffs have solely continued since. Time stops for nobody, and since 2023, there’ve been reductions by the handfuls or lots of, generally on a each day, even hourly foundation. What we thought was simply “survive til ’25” in 2023 or 2024 is now simply “survive” as games and their studios die within the blink of an eye fixed. Mixed with what appears like a weirdly muted Nintendo Switch 2 launch and america authorities going via another round of bullshit, in fact this commerce present feels funky.

Different components to this unusual feeling are owed completely to Summer time Recreation Fest. By no means is it extra clear when the business is chasing developments than an occasion like this, which had loads of souls and roguelikes and shooters of the house, aggressive, and extraction selection. The 2 genres’ reputation appeared to put on on viewers and remind us how we simply tire of issues we as soon as preferred. In comparison with PlayStation’s showcase earlier within the week, SGF additionally felt much less constant in what it needed to supply: Resident Evil Requiem and Wu-Tang: Rise of the Deceiver have been agreeable highs, different trailers appeared to indicate as much as be well mannered or didn’t actually land.

Extra problematically, 5 years in, Summer time Recreation Fest nonetheless feels prefer it has no actual id of its personal past an extension of the annual yr’s finish Recreation Awards. These ceremonies and accompanying sport reveals have a considerably completely different power due to musical performances, superstar appearances and often pleasant Muppet gags. With out these, SGF feels much less “enjoyable,” for lack of a greater phrase. It needs to be E3, however the huge pressers we tuned in for might generally be unhealthy as figureheads for sport publishers have been excessive off their very own provide or overindulged in nonsense they appeared to assume was humorous. This could’t be that, each as a result of publishers have their indvidual, extra common showcases, and it doesn’t need to be perceived as disrespectful to the medium and its viewers joyful to obtain recognition however not the criticism that comes with it.

Beforehand, Keighley has caught flack for failing to correctly acknowledge the business’s struggles, or doing so in a slipshod method. This yr’s Summer time Recreation Fest opened with him highlighting 2025’s present crop of best-selling video games, a few of which got here from groups a lot smaller than your common triple-A studio. Expedition 33’s been the largest and worst offender of this “honor”; because the RPG’s reveal and launch, it’s been lauded as a triumph for a developer with a headcount within the small dozens. However its seven-minute credits present that’s not the true story: sure, Sandfall has 33 or 34 employees, but it surely additionally had third-party animators, QA contractors, and localizers (and extra!) that helped make for a implausible debut title.

Keighley’s stressing of these small groups—one man made a brawler with simply the assistance of nine of his friends!—turns what was doubtless a well-intentioned acknowledgment of into extra gasoline for the fiery divide between indie and triple-A builders at a foul time for each. The narrative round sport improvement (and who makes them) is unhealthy sufficient due to ongoing layoffs and elevated participant harassment, and this can doubtless exacerbate issues. It’s a second that greatest represents the double-edged sword of Summer time Recreation Fest’s prominence and this explicit business figurehead: eventually, amid all of the flash and celebration this window into the business gives, somebody sours issues by placing their foot of their mouth.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and the whole lot you want to learn about the way forward for Doctor Who.